Patient question
My knee X-ray and MRI are normal, but my knee still hurts. Why?
Quick answer
A normal scan does not mean the pain is imagined. It may come from the hip or lower back, from tendons, bursae or nerves around the knee, or from overload that scans do not show. Re-examining the whole leg usually finds the answer, explains Dr. Pablo Gelber, knee surgeon at Aman Hospital in Doha.
Pain from outside the knee
- The hip: arthritis or other hip problems often refer pain to the front and inner knee
- The lower back: a trapped nerve root can cause pain, tingling or weakness around the knee
- Nerves around the knee: the saphenous nerve on the inner side, or the common peroneal nerve on the outer side, can be irritated after surgery or pressure
- Blood vessels: rarely, circulation problems or a clot cause calf and knee pain
Knee problems that scans can miss
- Patellofemoral pain: very common, and MRI is often normal
- Tendon and bursa problems, such as pes anserine bursitis on the inner knee
- Early cartilage softening that is subtle on imaging
- Muscle weakness and tightness changing how load passes through the knee
- Scans done in the wrong position: standing X-rays show narrowing that lying views can hide
What usually helps next
Bring all previous images and reports. Note exactly where it hurts, what triggers it, and whether you have back, groin or buttock pain, tingling or numbness. A fresh, careful examination of the hip, spine and knee often answers more than another scan. Sometimes a hip X-ray, a nerve test or a diagnostic injection is useful to confirm the source.
Getting a second look in Doha
At Aman Hospital Dr. Gelber reviews your previous scans, examines the whole leg and back, and explains in plain language whether the knee is truly the source. If the cause lies in the hip or spine, he will explain the findings and refer you on, rather than treat a knee that is not the problem.
Frequently asked questions
Should I ask for another MRI?
Not automatically. If the first MRI was of good quality and recent, a repeat rarely adds much unless symptoms have changed. Examination of the hip and back often matters more.
Could it be stress or in my head?
Pain is always real. Stress and poor sleep can amplify it, but a physical source should be looked for carefully before anyone suggests otherwise.
Related


